CISA vs CISM vs CRISC: Which is the Best Cybersecurity Certification?

As cyber threats continue to grow in scale and sophistication, the demand for skilled security professionals shows no signs of slowing. Cybersecurity certifications provide IT professionals with clear career pathways for developing in-demand skills while validating expertise to employers.

Three certifications particularly stand out – CISA, CISM, and CRISC – offered through the leading information security association ISACA. Each targets unique domains, making it important to understand how they differ.

Image source

This detailed guide will help professionals cut through common questions around choosing between CISA, CISM, and CRISC certifications. By exploring the focus, eligibility, and career opportunities of each, readers can determine the best fit based on their goals as auditors, managers, or risk practitioners.

Understanding Each Certification

Image source

Here are detailed descriptions of CISA, CISM, and CRISC certifications:

CISA (Certified Information Systems Auditor)

The CISA certification, which was created way back in 1978, formally validates the skills required to properly evaluate information systems for potential vulnerabilities, assess related risks and the effectiveness of applied controls, and ensure governance and compliance with auditing standards.

Professionals who take on the CISA certification are primarily responsible for carrying out independent audits to determine if an organization’s information systems policies and protocols are adequately addressing business needs and priorities while also appropriately managing risks. They must thoroughly assess if implemented controls are properly designed, correctly implemented, and functioning as intended to protect critical data resources and operations from both internal and external threats.

The CISA certification is most suitable for experienced IT auditors, both internal as well as external, who are tasked with digging deep into their clients’ IS infrastructure and processes to draw out gaps or inconsistencies vis-a-vis best practices and formalized frameworks.

The multiple-choice question CISA exam puts candidates’ mastery of a wide range of auditing standards, control objectives, risk management methodologies, governance principles, IT operational procedures, audit program design, testing, and reporting skills to the test.

Passing the rigorous CISA exam demonstrates their qualifications for taking charge of comprehensive system audits from start to end and providing value-adding recommendations backed by rock-solid evidence for continual enhancement of security postures and controls.

CISM (Certified Information Security Manager)

The CISM certification, which was first rolled out way back in 1993, recognizes top-level information security professionals with proven expertise and career achievements in strategically guiding as well as hands-on managing robust enterprise-scale security defenses, crisis responses, awareness campaigns, and all allied programs.

Applicants seeking the CISM credential are typically experienced security leaders and chief security officers serving as the voice of authority on matters relating to cyber risks and brand protection controls.

They play a pivotal advisory role in helping CXO teams establish optimized security budgets, keep tabs on compliance with industry directives and internal policy roadmaps, and drive organizational preparedness against ongoing cyber-criminal schemes and hacktivist maneuvers through proactive visibility and mitigation tactics.

The CISM certification exam is competency-based, utilizing realistic scenario-driven, case study-type questions to thoroughly evaluate candidates’ demonstrated ability to tie together security controls, frameworks, and priorities with overarching risk postures and corporate aims across four critical management domains.

Passing individuals have clearly shown they have what it takes to spearhead mature security functions and successfully tackle tough problems under pressure in C-suite-level responsibilities.

CRISC (Certified in Risk and Information Systems Control)

Unveiled in 2001, the CRISC certification validates the core skills possessed by professionals devoted to safeguarding large enterprises from significant information risks arising due to gaps or weaknesses in existing control structures, non-adherence with frameworks, improper asset classification, or inadequacies in employees’ security awareness.

CRISC-certified practitioners lend high-level guidance and subject matter expertise to C-level executives as well as cross-functional teams for aligning strategic programs, risk appetites, compliance obligations, and IT policies with relevant GRC standards and best practices.

Some key day-to-day activities these security pros engage in include taking a close look at operational controls, thoroughly testing for deficiencies, rolling out customized training regimes to plug human errors, automating repetitive tasks, and continuously feeding performance metrics into governance processes for optimized security spending decisions and well-prioritized corrections.

The focus of the CRISC exam is on evaluating candidates’ grasp of formal risk assessment methodologies, quantitative and qualitative risk analysis techniques, IT control selection criteria, auditing protocols, and approaches for translating theoretical risk management concepts into pragmatic implementations for lowering residual risks.

Comparison of CISA, CISM, and CRISC Certifications

This table provides a comprehensive comparison of the CISA, CISM, and CRISC certifications, highlighting their focus areas, target audiences, career opportunities, and more. It serves as a guide for professionals seeking to choose the most suitable certification based on their career goals and interests.

Aspect	CISA (Certified Information Systems Auditor)	CISM (Certified Information Security Manager)	CRISC (Certified in Risk and Information Systems Control)
Introduction	Validates skills in evaluating information systems for vulnerabilities, risk management, and auditing controls.	Recognizes expertise in information security management and leadership.	Validates skills in identifying, analyzing, and managing enterprise IT risks.
Core Focus Areas	Auditing standards, control objectives, risk management, IT operational procedures.	Information security governance, program management, risk management, and incident management.	Risk management, control frameworks, compliance, and governance processes.
Target Audience	IT auditors (internal and external), compliance officers, and forensic investigators.	Information security managers, security consultants, and CISOs	Risk managers, IT governance professionals, and control specialists.
Exam Structure	Multiple-choice questions covering five domains: auditing, governance, systems operation, etc.	Competency-based exam with scenario-driven questions across four domains.	Multiple-choice questions focusing on risk identification, analysis, response, and control.
Eligibility	Requires 5 years of work experience in IT auditing, control, or security.	Requires 5 years of experience in information security management.	Requires 3 years of work experience in IT risk management and control.
Career Opportunities	IT Auditor, Compliance Officer, Forensic Investigator, Consultant.	Information Security Manager, Security Consultant, Chief Information Security Officer (CISO).	Risk Analyst, Risk Manager, IT Governance Professional, Compliance Specialist.
Average Salary (USD)	Up to $140,000 (U.S.), varies by region and industry.	Up to $150,000 (U.S.), varies by region and industry.	Up to $130,000 (U.S.), varies by region and industry.
Global Demand	High demand in cloud computing, healthcare, financial services.	High demand in large corporations, particularly in strategic roles.	High demand in banking, insurance, energy, and other regulated industries.
Cost	$500-$800 for the exam; additional costs for study materials.	$500-$800 for the exam; additional costs for study materials.	$500-$800 for the exam; additional costs for study materials.
Preparation Time	2-4 months of study, with ongoing education required for maintenance.	2-4 months of study, with ongoing education required for maintenance.	2-4 months of study, with ongoing education required for maintenance.
Preparation Tips	Use ISACA’s CISA Review Manual and practice exams; focus on understanding auditing standards and IT controls.	Utilize CISM Review Manual and workshops; focus on governance and risk management scenarios.	Leverage CRISC Review Manual and peer discussions; focus on risk analysis and control implementation.
Industry Trends	Increasing integration of data analytics and AI in auditing.	Growing focus on cloud-native security and DevSecOps.	Expanding roles in blockchain, supply chain security, and critical infrastructure protection.
Future Prospects	Suited for those interested in auditing and compliance roles across industries.	Ideal for those aiming for security leadership roles and management positions.	Best for professionals focusing on risk management and governance in highly regulated sectors.

CISA vs CISM vs CRISC: Key Differences

Exam Structure

The exams for these highly sought-after certifications each have their own distinctive structure and format in testing the skills and comprehension of candidates. Both the CISM and CRISC examinations consist of 150 multiple-choice questions that must be thoroughly tackled and solved within the allotted time frame of 4 hours. Drawing deeply from the various competency domains, the questions posed span case studies, scenarios, and situational problems to effectively assess the real-world application of skills.

On the other hand, the CISA exam carries 200 questions to be dealt with during the 6-hour long sitting. All the exams are computer-based and administered on a continuous basis throughout the year at proctored testing centers globally, giving applicants the flexibility to sign up as per their schedule.

Eligibility

When opting to take the plunge and pursue these prestigious certifications, there are certain eligibility prerequisites that must be borne in mind and adhered to. For the CISM certification, a minimum of 5 years of professional experience in Information Security of which at least 3 years must be in a management capacity is a mandatory criteria. This work span can be accrued within the past 10 years. CRISC requires at least 3 years of related work experience with 2 years in 2 of the 4 domains.

For both CISM and CRISC, experience can be gained in the 5 years preceding attempting the exam. CISA demands a minimum of 5 years cumulative work experience in auditing, control or security plus 1 year experience in information systems auditing. These certification programs are quite stringent and selective regarding experience to ensure only seasoned professionals tackle their rigorous assessments.

Maintenance

Simply acquiring the certifications is not the end goal, maintaining credentialed status over the long run calls for continued dedication. All designations last 3 years and must be kept current through ongoing professional development. CRISC and CISM holders need to clock 20 CPE hours annually and amass 120 CPE credits every 3 years to stay certified.

Similarly, CISA renewal entails earning 120 CPE points within a 3-year window with a minimum of 20 CPEs in each renewal year. Non-compliance renders the certifications liable to revocation. In addition, ISACA also levies an annual membership fee for retaining the certifications. Clearly, preserving these elite badges of competence necessitates a conscientious commitment to lifelong learning even post-certification.

Career Pathways and Opportunities

Career Pathways and Opportunities abound for professionals seeking to enhance their skills and pursue new challenges through respected cybersecurity and risk management certifications from ISACA such as the CISA, CISM, and CRISC. These qualifications serve to boost career prospects across diverse industries and geographies while commanding competitive salaries commensurate with the role’s responsibilities.

CISA Career Pathways

The CISA qualification in particular carves out pathways for IT auditors, consultants, forensic investigators, and compliance officers looking to crystallize their abilities. With average salaries reaching upwards of $140,000 in the United States alone, opportunities exist in abundance on a global scale stretching from Europe to the Asia Pacific region in both the public and private sectors.

Growth industries pocketing CISA talent comprise cloud computing, healthcare, and financial services with their heightened regulatory demands and digital transformations underway. Professionals attaining the CISA badge themselves up for taking on contract work or staff roles helping organizations get a handle on controls, fortify defenses, and stick to guidelines. The certification lends itself to winding up at companies in assurance, accounting, and cybersecurity firms tasked with providing consultancy or testing services to clients.

CISM Career Pathways

For those aspiring to take charge of security strategic planning and oversee program implementation at a managerial level, the CISM offers a clear-cut route to follow. Options spring up as security program architects, directors, managers, or even Chief Information Security Officers (CISOs) at large corporations where risk mitigation becomes mission-critical.

With the CISM in hand, the capacity to ramp up strategic influence over boards of directors and C-suite executives deepens – proving indispensable for justifying budgets, and resources and selecting countermeasures.

While experience plays a big part in career progression and seniority attainment, CISM-certified professionals have been known to secure salaries topping $150,000 in North America especially where demand for proven security leadership holds strong. The CISM credentials stand head and shoulders above many other C-level qualifications and open the door for individuals to take their careers in cybersecurity to loftier heights.

CRISC Career Pathways

For enterprise risk analysts, advisors, managers, and governance roles that entail mitigating IT-related hazards, the CRISC packs clout and instills confidence. Positions leveraging the CRISC weave through sectors like banking, insurance, energ,y and other verticals where regulatory affairs and oversight play paramount.

Average incomes floating up to $130,000 come to light vastly in Western European hotbeds where financial services institutions drive risk certification sales. However, a heightened awareness of risks faced by digital transformation brings the CRISC into focus beyond traditional markets.

Opportunities arise in emerging territories along with Asia’s growing middle class and their demands for systems reliability and information protection. Multinationals ramping activities in high-growth regions from the Middle East to Southeast Asia look for qualified risk professionals certified through senior-recognized bodies such as ISACA to ramp up local operations while satisfying universal standards. The CRISC helps open doors to fulfilling risk responsibilities worldwide.

Exam Preparation Tips and Resources

ISACA endorses self-paced study 2-4 months in advance using official materials with practice exams benchmarking readiness. Seeking a review class aids focused preparation where mentorship complements self-study. Experience provides real-world context invaluable to exam comprehension.

CISA Preparation Tips

The guideline for CISA hopefuls is intensely delving into ISACA’s comprehensive CISA Review Manual cover to cover. This is essential to build thorough familiarity with each concept.

Additionally, Questionbank and PrepCast mock exams done under testing conditions help methodically zero in on weaker domains needing beefing up. Self-assessments performed periodically effectively flag such regions for directing extra learning energy. Regularly drilling sample questions from the manual further embeds knowledge.

CISM Preparation Tips

For CISM candidates, the prescription is initially exhausting the CISM Review Manual and taking diligent notes. Then knowledge retention is cemented by watching recorded CISM Aware workshops zeroing in on complex subjects requiring more unpacking.

Creating flashcards from manual details and workshop learnings and consistently testing oneself daily efficiently burns concepts into long-term memory. Crucial is planning mock exams at biweekly intervals to precisely monitor progress and spot deficiencies still requiring shoring up.

CRISC Preparation Tips

Aspiring CRISC certificants would benefit tremendously from thoroughly reading the CRISC Review Manual and Question Bank. This saturates one with risk management nuances. Vital too is hashing out complex standard details through discussions on LinkedIn user groups to gain complementary perspectives broadening comprehension.

Soliciting a peer to collaboratively pore over outcomes is invaluable for boosting absorption through explaining concepts. Their feedback allows for objectively identifying foggy areas necessitating enlightenment.

Role of Practice Exams and Simulations

For all certifications, mock exams play the pivotal role of unmasking potential blind spots well before the big exam through feedback. This provides the opportunity to strategically plug holes without risk of failure. Simulations embed real-world problem-solving acumen through hands-on practice of concepts.

Together, these tools are integral to scoring above average on the actual exam through methodically eliminating weaknesses and polishing strengths over months of dedicated preparation. They ready candidates to clinically think like experts when actually role playing on test day.

Expert Opinions and Industry Trends

ISACA’s president says ongoing talent shortfall drives 47% salary increases year-on-year, empowering CISA/CISM/CRISC holders increasingly. Cybersecurity Ventures predictions show a dedicated Information Security job rising to $201 billion globally underscoring continued need. CEOs identify the human risk element as their greatest concern which roles like CRISC address.

Advanced data analytics and AI skills merging with auditing attract CISA developments. Cloud-native DevSecOps’ emergence inspires DevOps-focused specializations. Blockchain, supply chain security, and critical infrastructure protection present expanding CRISC-style risk roles. Growth indicates constantly modernizing relevance making early attainment all the more worthwhile.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while CISA, CISM, and CRISC share overlapping knowledge to elevate joint pursuers, each targets specialized security career avenues through unique lenses of auditing, management, and risk mitigation. Choosing the certification aligning the closest individual and organizational needs optimizes professional development fueling rewarding career ascents. Leveraging this guide, professionals can make informed selections capitalizing on ever-evolving opportunities in this thriving domain.

To aid in making an informed decision, CCS Learning Academy offers comprehensive courses on CISA, CISM, and CRISC. These courses are designed to provide in-depth knowledge, hands-on experience, and expert guidance to help you excel in your certification journey. Whether you’re aiming to strengthen your auditing skills with CISA, lead security programs with CISM, or manage enterprise risks with CRISC, CCS Learning Academy equips you with the tools and confidence to achieve your career goals.

FAQs