CASP vs CISM: Which Is the Best Certification for Your Career?

As cyber threats ramp up each day, the demand for skilled cybersecurity professionals has skyrocketed. Earning an advanced credential has become almost indispensable for moving up the career ladder in this high-stakes field.

Amongst various certifications available, the CompTIA Advanced Security Practitioner (CASP) and Certified Information Security Manager (CISM) certifications stand out as attractive options for IT experts looking to enhance their expertise and employability. However, choosing between CASP and CISM is not easy as they each cater to different skill sets and career aspirations.

This article digs deeper into both certifications to break down their focus areas, exam formats, salary implications, typical job roles and more to help you pick the most suitable certification based on your long-term career goals.

Understanding CASP and CISM Certifications

Two certifications that often arise in discussions are the CompTIA Advanced Security Practitioner (CASP) and the Certified Information Security Manager (CISM) from ISACA. To make an informed decision between the two, it is imperative to gain a thorough understanding of what each encompasses.

The CASP is an advanced certification carried out by CompTIA to validate one’s technical skills for putting forward, implementing as well as managing secure solutions across all computing environments and disciplines. To earn the CASP, candidates must pass a single performance-based exam testing skills in domains like Enterprise Security, Risk Management, Research and Analysis, and the Integration of computing, communications, and business disciplines.

CompTIA recommends a minimum of 10 years of IT experience, with 5+ years of hands-on security experience to attempt this certification. Major. 70% of CISM holders report tangible on-the-job improvements. And 42% have cashed in with a pay bump after adding the certification to their resume.

On the other hand, the CISM from ISACA is aimed at certifying information security management expertise. It accredits an individual’s strategic abilities for developing policies, overseeing risk management methodologies and taking charge of an organization’s overall information security governance program.

CISM examines candidates on domains such as Information Security Governance, Risk Management, Program Development and Incident Response. To qualify for the CISM exam, at least 5 years of overall work experience with 3 years specific to security management is mandated.

Comparison of Roles and Responsibilities

Image source

While both certifications deal with cybersecurity at an advanced level, there is a clear differentiation in the job roles and responsibilities they align with:

The CASP matches technical cybersecurity roles including Security Engineer, Security Architect, Security Analyst and Security Consultant. Jobs requiring extensive hands-on skills to implement, manage and maintain security controls fall under its purview.

On the flip side, the CISM is more tailored towards managerial and leadership information security positions like Chief Information Security Officer (CISO), Information Security Manager and Compliance Officer. It targets positions where developing security programs, minimizing organizational risk and steering security strategy are core responsibilities.

In essence, the CASP focuses on the technical execution of cybersecurity tasks across the enterprise. CISM concentrates more on the administrative, planning and strategic aspects of governing an organization’s overall security posture.

Purpose and Scope of Each Certification

At their core, CASP and CISM certifications have been designed with distinct objectives in mind:

The CompTIA Advanced Security Practitioner certification serves to set a new higher industry standard for hands-on security practice. It acts as a benchmark verifying in-depth technical know-how for implementing and managing security controls effectively.

On the other hand, the Certified Information Security Manager credential from ISACA aims to recognize information security professionals with abilities to lead strategic security functions. It targets skills vital for assessing risk, developing programs and providing governance in accordance with an organization’s security goals and policies.

In terms of scope, CASP extensively covers technical security implementation factors while keeping compliance and business considerations in view. CISM casts a broader net by instilling a management mindset focused on handling information risk across the business.

Ultimately, CASP targets validating applied security expertise. CISM focuses more on confirming managerial command over an information security program at an enterprise scale.

Eligibility Requirements & Exam Details

Though both certifications require deep security proficiency, there exist notable differences in the prerequisites mandated:

CASP

• 10+ years of IT industry experience with at least 5 years spent in hands-on security roles  
• Single 165-minute, 90 question performance-based written exam
• Minimum passing score of 750 points (out of 900)

CISM

• 5+ years of overall professional work history with 3 years specifically in security management
• 150 multiple-choice questions to finish within 4 hours  
• Minimum passing mark of 450 points (out of 800) required

The CASP exam thoroughly evaluates technical implementation skills through scenario and task-based questions. CISM on the other hand employs a broader multiple-choice format to assess situational judgment and risk advisory abilities at a management/leadership level. Additionally, CISM’s experience criteria necessitate proof of growth into an elevated security role.

Job Opportunities

The effort put into CASP and CISM preparation unlocks many prestigious cybersecurity career moves:

CASP

The updated CASP certification demonstrates advanced knowledge and skills in cybersecurity. It covers topics like risk management, enterprise security, research and analysis, and integration of computing, communications and business disciplines. CASP is recommended or required by many employers for roles like:

• Security Architect: Designs and develops secure network architectures and systems to protect organizational assets and data. CASP shows skills in areas like cryptography, vulnerabilities, threat intelligence, and compliance.  
• Security Engineer: Implements and monitors security controls and policies. Troubleshoots issues. CASP validates understanding of identity and access management, firewalls, endpoint security, etc.
• Technical Lead Analyst: Leads cybersecurity operations and incident response. Analyzes threats and vulnerabilities. CASP proves proficiency in security monitoring, penetration testing, disaster recovery, and more.  
• Application Security Engineer: Assesses and fortifies software application security. CASP demonstrates knowledge of app security concepts like input validation, access control, encryption, and DevSecOps.
• Major organizations like the U.S. Army, Dell, Verizon and Booz Allen Hamilton look for CASP certified professionals.

Other employers recommending or requiring CASP include:

• U.S. Navy
• Network Solutions, LLC
• One Source Technologies Inc.

CISM

There are several common positions that CISM holders can look into based on their background, abilities, schooling, and qualifications.

Some of the typical roles in the arena of Information Security Management(CISM) are:

• Security Administrator: Oversees and carries out security policies to safeguard systems and data.
• Security Analyst: Assesses vulnerabilities and risks to develop solutions for protecting sensitive information.
• Security Engineer: Designs and builds secure networks, systems, and applications.
• Security Architect: Lays out and integrates security controls across an organization’s systems and infrastructure.
• Security Software Developer: Writes code for tools and applications that boost security and block threats.
• Cryptographer: Develops schemes and protocols to encrypt sensitive data and messages.
• Cryptanalyst: Works to decipher encrypted information and break codes.
• Security Consultant: Advises organizations on best practices for shoring up vulnerabilities and responding to incidents.

The CISM opens up possibilities for specializing in numerous facets of information security management. By pairing certification with experience, CISM holders can break into and move up in the field.

So in essence, technical hands-on roles suit CASP more. CISM matches leadership/managerial security jobs regulating risk at a strategic corporate level.

Earning Potential and Job Opportunities

Certifications open doors to better salaries and career prospects. Let’s see how CASP and CISM stack up in terms of compensation packages and relevant job roles.

Average Salaries for CISM Professionals

CISM professionals really take home the bacon with their paychecks. On average, they rack up about $123,582 annually in the United States. When you factor in bonuses and other compensation, the total pay package comes out to around $151,557 per year.

So, these information security managers are definitely bringing home big bucks and living large with the lucrative salaries they command. Their specialized skills and in-demand expertise allow them to cash in and make bank in the cybersecurity field.

If you’re looking to get paid and maximize your earning potential, getting CISM certified seems to be a surefire way to fatten your wallet. The high pay really seals the deal for pursuing this career path.

Average Salaries for CASP Professionals

As one of the premium cybersecurity certifications available today, CASP opens up lucrative career opportunities and commands impressive salaries.

According to Payscale, the average salary for CASP certified professionals in the United States ranges from $91K to $115K. However, this broad average does not tell the full story. The actual earning potential with CASP depends on several factors:

The job role and seniority level have a big impact on CASP salaries. Entry-level cyber security analysts may start around $65,000, while senior security architects and CISOs can earn well over $150,000. Mid-career security engineers and leads often make between $95,000 to $120,000. Higher positions and specialized roles like cloud security typically result in higher pay.

Process of Obtaining CASP and CISM Certifications

While both tests lay stress on security acumen, their certification paths involve differences:

CASP

1. Meet experience guidelines
2. Register and pay CompTIA fee for the single 165-minute performance-based exam
3. Pass exam with a score of minimum 750 points
4. Receive digital badge and certificate upon accomplishment

CISM

1. Fulfill 5 years overall, 3 years managerial experience criteria
2. Register for the exam after submitting experience proof
3. Pay ISACA registration and exam fees
4. Take the 4-hour, 150 question multiple-choice test
5. Achieve a passing mark of 450+ points to get certified
6. Continuously earn CPE credits to maintain credential

Notably, CISM candidates must first satisfy eligibility norms before registering for its exam. Also, maintaining CISM involves keeping up with continuing professional education, absent for CASP.

Preparing for CASP and CISM Certification Exams

To pass these rigorous exams, candidates need structured preparation factoring exam trends:

For CASP:

• Hands-on lab practice with security tools and simulators is key
• Study CompTIA’s exam objectives and official review guide meticulously  
• Solve previous year question banks and simulated tests thoroughly
• Refresh technical security skills through self-paced learning
• Consult training videos, online classes, and security certification books

For CISM:

• Excelling at situational judgment through scenario based questions    
• Having strong command over risk management methodologies
• Brushing concepts through ISACA’s review materials over 6+ months
• Appearing for rigorous mocks simulating the real exam format
• Gaining additional insights from peer group discussions

What works best is customizing one’s study style while allocating time for regular revisions and simulations under timed conditions. Supplementing online resources with classroom programs can also help retain concepts better. With such focused preparation, both exams can be cracked on the first attempt.

Exam Preparation Resources

Here are some insider tips to crack these exams:

• Read official exam objectives and prep guides shared by CompTIA and ISACA to structure your preparation accordingly.
• Enroll in a CompTIA or ISACA authorized training course for classroom learning. Their training programs flesh out concepts well.   
• Refer study materials from top review providers like Sybex, Boson, Total Seminars and Infosec Institute who offer practice tests, flashcards and online video lessons.
• Use freely available resources like Professor Messer YouTube playlists, Cybrary.it courses, CBT Nuggets videos which complement paid options.
• Join study groups online or via local meetups. Collaborating and clearing doubts with peers yields better retention.
• Take mock exams to identify weak areas. Repeated drills help retaining on tough topics.  
• Allow sufficient gap between mock exams and the final one to review the whole syllabus thoroughly. Last-minute cramming may do more harm than good.

Which Certification is Right for You?

With a full understanding of these certifications, potential candidates can cogitate on factors to determine the optimal one:

• Current Role: Those technical in present roles should consider CASP. Management inclined roles suit CISM better.
• Experience: Meet CISM’s 5/3 years criteria or not? CASP may be quicker if experience is lacking.  
• Career Goals: Aiming for technical leadership? CASP demonstrates expertise. Strategic leadership? CISM exemplifies capabilities.  
• Interest Areas: Keen on technical implementation or governance/strategy development? Choose accordingly.
• Time/Cost Investment: How much time is there to study? CISM preparation requires 6+ months commonly.
• Organizational Needs: Understand employer preferences to pick what aligns with market demand.

Weighing these aspects provides clarity on picking the certification maximizing career growth prospects right now and in the future.

Conclusion

At the core, CASP certification concentrates on hands-on security controls, architecture and operations while CISM certification deals with risk, policy and program management. For individuals wanting to implement security solutions and take a technical lead role, CASP aligns better. On the other hand, security managers steering holistic governance programs are better served pursuing the CISM.

If career growth into leadership roles excites you, then CISM positions would present greater exposure and responsibilities over time. But information security practitioners disliking management duties may prefer more technical designations like CASP.

Careers that need interacting with technical teams on a daily basis may opt for CASP to gain deeper expertise and credibility with peers. Still, security startups and smaller organizations typically seek the rounded management experience conferred by CISM.

Ultimately, the right decision boils down to one’s job functions, company needs and aspirations for the future. Speaking with mentors and co-workers provides concrete advice tailored to your context. Keep an eye on changing industry dynamics too which certification holds more pull in coming years. With due diligence, you can determine whether CASP or CISM elevates your career to greater heights.

Whichever certification you pursue, be sure to use quality exam prep materials. CCS Learning Academy offers comprehensive online courses for both CASP and CISM. Our expert instructors, hands-on labs, and adaptive learning technology ensure you’ll be fully prepared to pass your exam the first time. Visit CCS Learning Academy today to enroll and advance your cybersecurity career!

FAQs