GSLC vs CISM: Which Is the Best Cybersecurity Certification?

In the world of cybersecurity, professionals are constantly seeking ways to validate their expertise and stand out in a highly competitive field. Two certifications that have gained significant recognition are the GIAC Security Leadership Certification (GSLC) and the Certified Information Security Manager (CISM). These credentials are designed to equip professionals with the knowledge and skills necessary to navigate the complex challenges of information security management effectively.

As the demand for cybersecurity leaders continues to soar, choosing the right certification can be a game-changer for your career trajectory. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive deep into the intricacies of GSLC and CISM, exploring their respective benefits, exam requirements, job prospects, and salaries. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of which certification aligns best with your professional aspirations, empowering you to make an informed decision that propels your career to new heights.

What is GSLC?

The GIAC Security Leadership Certification (GSLC) is an advanced-level credential offered by the Global Information Assurance Certification (GIAC). It is specifically tailored for professionals who are, or aspire to be, in managerial or leadership positions within the cybersecurity domain. This certification focuses on equipping individuals with the knowledge and skills necessary to navigate the strategic aspects of security management, policy development, and effective communication.

GSLC is designed for a diverse range of professionals, including information security managers, information security professionals with leadership or managerial responsibilities, and information technology management personnel. By earning this certification, individuals demonstrate their ability to align cybersecurity strategies with business objectives, manage and safeguard an organization’s information assets, and lead security teams effectively.

The GSLC curriculum covers a wide array of topics, such as cryptography concepts and applications, incident response and business continuity planning, managing security operations centers, project management, application security, security policy development, risk management frameworks, and vulnerability management. This comprehensive approach ensures that GSLC holders possess a well-rounded understanding of the technical and managerial aspects of cybersecurity.

What is CISM?

The Certified Information Security Manager (CISM) is an advanced-level certification offered by the Information Systems Audit and Control Association (ISACA). It is globally recognized as a benchmark for professionals seeking to validate their expertise in developing, managing, and overseeing information security programs within organizations.

CISM is tailored for information security managers and professionals who are tasked with management responsibilities in the cybersecurity domain. This certification reinforces international security practices and verifies that the holder possesses the necessary skills to design, manage, and assess information security programs effectively.

The CISM curriculum is structured around four core domains: information security governance, information risk management, information security program development and management, and information security incident management. By mastering these domains, CISM holders demonstrate their ability to establish and maintain robust security governance frameworks, identify and mitigate risks, develop and implement comprehensive security programs, and respond effectively to security incidents.

Benefits of GSLC

Here are some benefits of GSLC:

• Comprehensive Management Focus: GSLC is specifically designed for professionals seeking leadership roles in cybersecurity management. It equips individuals with the knowledge and skills necessary to navigate the strategic and operational aspects of managing security teams, programs, and initiatives.
• Practical Application: The GSLC curriculum emphasizes the practical application of security knowledge in real-world scenarios. It covers a wide range of topics, including cryptography, incident response, project management, security policy development, and risk management frameworks, ensuring that GSLC holders are well-prepared to tackle complex challenges in the field.
• Vendor-Neutral: GSLC is a vendor-neutral certification, which means it is not tied to any specific product or technology. This versatility allows GSLC holders to apply their knowledge across various organizations and industries, enhancing their career mobility and flexibility.
• Continuing Professional Development: To maintain the GSLC certification, holders are required to engage in continuing professional education (CPE) activities. This ongoing learning process ensures that GSLC professionals stay up-to-date with the latest trends, best practices, and emerging threats in the cybersecurity landscape.

Benefits of CISM

Here are some benefits of CISM:

• Global Recognition: CISM is a globally recognized and respected certification in the field of information security management. It is widely acknowledged by organizations worldwide, enhancing the credibility and marketability of CISM holders.
• Comprehensive Knowledge Base: The CISM curriculum covers a broad range of topics, including information security governance, risk management, program development, and incident management. This comprehensive knowledge base equips CISM holders with the skills necessary to navigate the complexities of managing information security programs effectively.
• Rigorous Examination Process: Obtaining the CISM certification requires passing a rigorous examination that assesses candidates’ knowledge and understanding of various information security management concepts and practices. This stringent evaluation process ensures that CISM holders possess the necessary expertise to excel in their roles.

Professional Development: CISM holders are required to engage in ongoing professional development activities to maintain their certification. This commitment to continuous learning ensures that CISM professionals stay abreast of the latest trends, regulations, and best practices in the field of information security management.

Differences Between CISM and GSLC

While both CISM and GSLC are advanced-level certifications focused on information security management, they differ in several key aspects:

Scope and Focus

CISM has a broader scope, covering various aspects of information security governance, risk management, program development, and incident management. GSLC, on the other hand, places a stronger emphasis on the strategic and operational aspects of leading security teams, managing projects, and developing security policies.

Prerequisites

CISM has a strict prerequisite of five years of cumulative experience in information security, with at least three years in information security management roles. GSLC, on the other hand, does not have specific experience requirements, making it more accessible to professionals who may not have extensive management experience but aspire to leadership roles.

Exam Structure

The CISM exam consists of 150 multiple-choice questions to be completed within four hours, while the GSLC exam comprises 115 questions to be answered within three hours.

Continuing Professional Development

CISM holders are required to earn 20 CPE credits annually and 120 CPE credits over a three-year period to maintain their certification. GSLC holders must renew their certification every four years, with specific CPE requirements varying based on individual circumstances.

Similarities Between CISM and GSLC

Despite their differences, CISM and GSLC share some notable similarities:

Advanced-Level Certifications

Both CISM and GSLC are considered advanced-level certifications, designed for professionals seeking to validate their expertise in information security management and leadership.

Management Focus

While CISM has a broader scope, both certifications emphasize the management aspects of cybersecurity, equipping professionals with the knowledge and skills necessary to lead and oversee security programs and teams effectively.

Continuing Professional Development

Both CISM and GSLC require holders to engage in ongoing professional development activities to maintain their certifications, ensuring that they remain up-to-date with the latest trends and best practices in the field.

Global Recognition

CISM and GSLC are widely recognized and respected certifications within the cybersecurity industry, both nationally and internationally.

Exam Requirements

The following are GSLC and CISM exam requirements:

GSLC Exam Requirements

To obtain the GSLC certification, candidates must pass a proctored exam consisting of 115 questions. The exam has a time limit of three hours, and candidates must achieve a minimum score of 65% to pass. GIAC recommends that candidates complete an affiliate training course or engage in self-study to prepare for the exam effectively.

CISM Exam Requirements

To earn the CISM certification, candidates must meet the following requirements:

• Professional Experience: Candidates must possess a minimum of five years of cumulative paid experience in information security, with at least three years in information security management roles.
• Exam: Candidates must pass a computer-based, multiple-choice exam consisting of 150 questions. The exam has a duration of four hours, and candidates must achieve a scaled score of 450 (out of 800) to pass.
• Continuing Professional Education (CPE): CISM holders are required to earn 20 CPE credits annually and 120 CPE credits over a three-year period to maintain their certification.
• Code of Professional Ethics: CISM holders must adhere to ISACA’s Code of Professional Ethics.

Exam Details

The following are GSLC and CISM exam details:

CISM Exam Details

The CISM exam is a rigorous assessment that covers four core domains:

1. Information Security Governance (24%)
2. Information Risk Management (30%)
3. Information Security Program Development and Management (27%)
4. Information Security Incident Management (19%)

The CISM exam is computer-based and consists of 150 multiple-choice questions. Candidates have four hours to complete the exam, which is offered in various languages, including English, Japanese, Korean, and Spanish. The exam can be taken either through an online remote proctored testing appointment or at an in-person testing center.

GSLC Exam Details

The GSLC exam is a comprehensive assessment that covers a wide range of topics related to information security management, technical controls, and governance. The exam is designed to evaluate a candidate’s ability to detect, respond to, and protect against information security threats.

The GSLC exam consists of 115 questions, and candidates have three hours to complete the exam. The exam is web-based and can be taken either through remote proctoring or at an on-site testing center provided by Pearson VUE.

Unlike the CISM exam, the GSLC exam is an open-book format, which means candidates can reference printed materials during the exam. However, they are not permitted to use the internet or computers for reference.

Exam Difficulty

The following are GSLC and CISM exam difficulties:

GSLC Exam Difficulty

The GSLC exam is considered a challenging assessment due to its broad coverage of both technical and managerial aspects of cybersecurity. Candidates are expected to demonstrate a deep understanding of topics such as cryptography, incident response, security policy development, risk management frameworks, and vulnerability management.

While the open-book format may seem advantageous, it can also pose challenges as candidates must effectively navigate and reference the provided materials within the time constraint. Proper preparation through training courses, self-study, or practical experience is crucial for success in the GSLC exam.

CISM Exam Difficulty

The CISM exam is widely regarded as one of the most challenging certifications in the field of information security management. The exam’s difficulty stems from its comprehensive coverage of four core domains, each requiring a thorough understanding of various concepts, principles, and best practices.

The information security governance and risk management domains, which account for 54% of the exam, are particularly challenging as they require a deep understanding of governance frameworks, risk assessment methodologies, and risk mitigation strategies.

Additionally, the CISM exam’s rigorous professional experience requirements ensure that candidates possess practical knowledge and hands-on experience in information security management, further contributing to the exam’s difficulty level.

Salary and Job Opportunities

The following are GSLC and CISM salary and job opportunities:

GSLC Salary and Job Opportunities

Earning the GSLC certification can open doors to a wide range of career opportunities in the cybersecurity management field.

GSLC holders are well-positioned for roles such as:

• Security Director
• Information Assurance Manager
• Security Program Leader
• Compliance Officer

According to various salary surveys, the average annual salary for GSLC-certified professionals can range from $90,000 to $130,000, depending on factors such as location, industry, and level of experience.

CISM Salary and Job Opportunities

The CISM certification is highly valued by employers and can significantly enhance career prospects in the field of information security management. CISM holders are often sought after for roles such as:

• Chief Information Security Officer (CISO)
• Information Security Manager
• IT Security Architect
• IT Risk Manager

According to PayScale, the average annual salary for CISM-certified professionals in the United States ranges from $114,000 to $167,000, with variations based on factors like location, industry, and years of experience.

GSLC vs CISM Pros and Cons

To help you make an informed decision, let’s explore the pros and cons of each certification:

GSLC Pros

• Focuses on practical application of security knowledge in real-world scenarios
• Covers a wide range of topics, including cryptography, incident response, and project management
• No specific experience requirements, making it more accessible
• Open-book exam format

GSLC Cons

• More niche and focused on leadership and management aspects
• May not appeal to professionals seeking a more technical certification
• Limited recognition compared to CISM in some industries

CISM Pros

• Globally recognized and respected certification
• Comprehensive coverage of information security management domains
• Rigorous exam process ensures expertise
• Enhances career prospects and earning potential

CISM Cons

• Strict experience requirements may be a barrier for some professionals
• Challenging exam with a broad scope of knowledge required
• Ongoing professional development requirements for maintaining certification

CISM and GSLC Certification Cost

The cost of obtaining and maintaining a certification is an important factor to consider when evaluating your options.

CISM Certification Cost

Exam Fee: $575 for ISACA members, $760 for non-members

Annual Maintenance Fee: $45 for ISACA members, $60 for non-membersContinuing Professional Education (CPE) Costs: Varies based on the courses or activities chosen

GSLC Certification Cost

Exam Fee: Typically ranges from $979 to $1,299, including practice exams and study materials

Annual Maintenance Fee: Approximately $429Renewal Fee: Varies based on the renewal method chosen

It’s important to note that these costs are subject to change, and additional expenses may be incurred for study materials, training courses, or exam retakes.

Conclusion

Choosing between the GSLC and CISM certifications is a critical decision that can significantly impact your career trajectory in the field of cybersecurity management. Both certifications offer unique advantages and cater to different professional aspirations.

If you are primarily focused on developing your leadership and strategic management skills within the cybersecurity domain, the GSLC certification may be the ideal choice. Its emphasis on practical application, incident response, and policy development equips you with the knowledge and skills necessary to navigate the complexities of leading security teams and initiatives effectively.

On the other hand, if your goal is to validate your comprehensive expertise in information security governance, risk management, and program development, the globally recognized CISM certification may be the better option. Its rigorous exam process and stringent experience requirements ensure that CISM holders possess the depth of knowledge and practical experience necessary to excel in senior-level information security management roles.

Ultimately, the decision between GSLC and CISM should be guided by your career aspirations, areas of expertise, and willingness to invest time and resources in obtaining and maintaining these certifications. Whichever path you choose, earning either of these credentials will undoubtedly enhance your credibility, open doors to new opportunities, and position you as a valuable asset in the ever-evolving cybersecurity landscape.

CCS Learning Academy offers two prestigious certifications: GIAC Security Leadership Certification (GSLC) and Certified Information Security Manager (CISM). CCS Learning Academy offers flexible online and in-person classes to suit your schedule. Invest in your future and choose the certification that aligns with your career goals. Whether it’s GSLC or CISM, our programs are designed to help you achieve cybersecurity excellence.

Enroll today and take the next step in your cybersecurity career with CCS Learning Academy!

FAQs